Saturday, April 8, 2017

Group Analysis of Paper #4

Group #1: Jean, Lorna, Yulia, Jhonny.

Thesis:“If hate groups are allowed to be legal, then millions of Americans needs a distinction between where free speech does and does not apply to the violence perpetrated by hate groups.”
We agreed that the thesis was unclear and seemed to be begging a question rather than being a thesis. We were not sure what the paper was about or what the author’s topic is.
Introduction: There was no strong hook in the essay, and was disjointed and all over the place.
Body Paragraphs:
            Effective (Strong): Very articulate. Have a topic sentence and a good transition.
            Needs Editing (Weak): Does not define keywords and has no background information.
General Comments:No abstract. Needs a more creative title. Should use the ‘quote-sandwich’ more. Generally unorganized and undeveloped. Closer to a research proposal than a research paper. There is a solid paper in the future but this is not it. Not complete sentence. Not cited appropriately. Needs an abstract.


No comments:

Post a Comment

MEMO

MEMORANDUM TO: All Public School Staffs & Students FROM: Lorna Jeremy, Student At John Jay College Of Criminal Justice DATE: ...